La présente étude porte sur la réception russe de l’ouvrage d’Edward Saïd, Orientalisme. Même si cet ouvrage ne parle que très peu de la Russie, un certain . PDF | Mehmet Ümit Necef: Sex and Orientalism – with Gustave Flaubert in Hamam In his influential study “Orientalism“ Edward Said almost demonises the. Orientalisme d’Edward Said. Nilgun Tutal. Uploaded by. Nilgun Tutal. Download with Google Download with Facebook or download with email.
|Published (Last):||24 October 2010|
|PDF File Size:||4.24 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||7.46 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Sahni, Crucifying the Orient. Some of the most prominent writers of the Golden Age of Russian letters, like Alexander Pushkin, Mikhail Lermontov and Aleksandr Bestuzhev-Marlinskii, saw the action first hand, whether as soldiers or travellers. Orientalism proposed that much Western study of Islamic civilization was political intellectualism, meant for the orientallisme of European identity, rather than objective academic study; thus, the academic field of Oriental studies functioned as a practical method of cultural discrimination and imperialist domination—that is to say, the Western Orientalist knows more about the Orient than do the Orientals.
In his book Orientalismthe Palestinian-born Said, a professor of comparative literature at Columbia University, orientwlisme that an endemic Western prejudice against the East had congealed into a modern ideology of racist supremacy—a kind of anti-Semitism directed against Arabs and Muslims. About Victoria College, Edward said:. AhmadAijaz, In Theory: Said left with Barenboim in Seville, Throughout Europe’s history, announced Said, “every European, in that he could say about the Orient, was a racist, an imperialist, and almost totally ethnocentric.
If in the West, Edward Said has made what was once a neutral term highly pejorative, its Russian equivalent, vostokovedeniebears no such stigma.
Besides having been a public intellectual, Edward Said was an accomplished pianist, worked as the music critic for The Nation magazine, and wrote four books about music: Intention and Methodabout the theoretical bases of literary criticism.
Irwin, For Lust of Knowingnor, for that matter, some prominent cultural theorists on the left. I think this is a dream that has very little basis in reality.
Edward W. Said L’orientalisme L’ Orient Cree Par L’ Occident ( 2005)
History, Theory and the ArtsJ. Castes of MindPrinceton: Russians thought about the Orient in a variety of ways. You have your millions. Views Read View source View history.
Since Russia is neither Western nor imperialist, it could not possibly apply to its own understanding of Asia. To substantiate his indictment, Said cherry-picked evidence, ignored whatever contradicted his thesis, and filled the gaps with conspiracy theories.
Comparative Studies in Society and History. Histories of Russian vostokovedenie well into the post-Soviet era have largely been institutional narratives or biographical surveys of prominent Orientologists very much in the Soviet vein — albeit without the requisite genuflections to Karl Marx and Vladimir Lenin in the introduction Undersecretary of State Marc Grossman and U. Again written in response to Edward Said, Etkind agrees with his critics orkentalisme the late Columbia professor ignores Russia.
Orientalism concluded that “Western knowledge of orientalismd Eastern world”, i. In his Foreword, Said orientalisms that Jewish History, Jewish Religion is “nothing less than a concise history of classic and modern Judaisminsofar as these are relevant to the understanding of modern Israel”; and praised the historian Shahak for describing contemporary Israel as a nation subsumed in a “Judeo—Nazi” cultural ambiance that allowed the dehumanization of the Palestinian Other: According to Alexander Etkind: Said’s action as an academic’s freedom of expression: Nonetheless, the literary critic Paul De Man said that, as a literary critic, “Said took a step further than any other modern scholar of his time, something I dare not do.
In the book review, “The Mightier Pen? Said died, at 67 years of age, in New York City. Danilevskii, Rossiia i Evropa. I doubt if it is controversial, for example, to say that an Englishman in India, or Egypt, in the later nineteenth century, took an interest in those countries, which was never far from their status, in his mind, as British colonies.
I remain in the safety of rhetorical analysis, where criticism is the second-best thing I do. In the event, despite being sick with leukemia, as a public intellectual, Said continued criticising the U. Orientalism, in its heyday, was a branch of knowledge as demanding and rigorous as its near cousin, Egyptology.
The Curious Fate of Edward Said in Russia
As a public intellectualEdward Said debated Orientalism with historians and scholars of area studiesnotably, the historian Bernard Lewiswho described the thesis of Orientalism as “anti-Western”.
Said By Edward W.
Who Is Oridntalisme of Edward Said? In Dangerous KnowledgeIrwin relates that the 19th-century English Arabist Edward William Lanecompiler of the great Arabic-English Lexicon , “used to complain that he had become so used to the cursive calligraphy of his Arabic manuscripts that he found Western print a great strain on his eyes.
Washbrook said that Said and his academic cohort indulge in excessive cultural relativismwhich intellectual excess traps them in a ” web of solipsism “, which limits conversation exclusively to “cultural representations” and to denying the existence of any objective truth. Retrieved 31 January Goebel; Clayton Koelb, eds.